OMOfferMarket

Off-Market Archive

No longer actively listed

Off market since May 13, 2026. Photos, details, and location data are preserved for neighborhood research and comparable analysis.

Last listed

$139,990.00

Off-Market

2531 N Tacoma Ave

Indianapolis, IN 46218, USA

List price

$139,990

Multi-unit house

Photographs

· interior, exterior, and the details that matter.

Drop photographs here, or click to browse

Interior and exterior shots welcomed — the first photo is your headline.

Photographs

Picture of listing, number 0
Picture of listing, number 1
Picture of listing, number 2
Picture of listing, number 3
Picture of listing, number 4
Picture of listing, number 5
Picture of listing, number 6
Picture of listing, number 7
Picture of listing, number 8
Picture of listing, number 9
Picture of listing, number 10
Picture of listing, number 11
Picture of listing, number 12
Picture of listing, number 13
Picture of listing, number 14
Picture of listing, number 15
Picture of listing, number 16
Picture of listing, number 17
Picture of listing, number 18
Picture of listing, number 19
Picture of listing, number 20
Picture of listing, number 21
Picture of listing, number 22
Picture of listing, number 23
Picture of listing, number 24
Picture of listing, number 25
Picture of listing, number 26
Picture of listing, number 27
Picture of listing, number 28
Picture of listing, number 29
Picture of listing, number 30
Picture of listing, number 31
Picture of listing, number 32
Picture of listing, number 33
Picture of listing, number 34
Picture of listing, number 35
Picture of listing, number 36
Picture of listing, number 37
Picture of listing, number 38
Picture of listing, number 39
Picture of listing, number 40
Picture of listing, number 41
Picture of listing, number 42
Picture of listing, number 43
Picture of listing, number 44
Picture of listing, number 45
Picture of listing, number 46
Picture of listing, number 47
Picture of listing, number 48
Picture of listing, number 49
Picture of listing, number 50
Picture of listing, number 51
Picture of listing, number 52
Picture of listing, number 53
Picture of listing, number 54
Picture of listing, number 55
Picture of listing, number 56
Picture of listing, number 57
Picture of listing, number 58
Picture of listing, number 59
Picture of listing, number 60
Picture of listing, number 61
Picture of listing, number 62
Picture of listing, number 63
Picture of listing, number 64
Picture of listing, number 65
Picture of listing, number 66
Picture of listing, number 67
Picture of listing, number 68
Picture of listing, number 69
Picture of listing, number 70
Picture of listing, number 71

Photos of the property

Explore the location

· from aerial to streetside.

Click to explore Street View
Scroll past freely — Street View won't take over until you activate it.

Story

>>> CLICK HERE FOR ALL PHOTOS <<<

2531 N Tacoma Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46218 WALKTHROUGH THURSDAY 5/8/25 MUST TEXT 317-751-2308 FOR ACCESS AND TIME
ASKING PRICE
$ 139,990 CASH (OR BEST OFFER)
AFTER REPAIR VALUE $ 165,000 Turnkey Condition. Very well-maintained. Fully rented, strong rents with long-term stable tenants. Better condition/price than currently on the market for that area!! Amazing find with Instant Equity!! RENTAL ESTIMATE $ 1,675 Current Rents $1,675 total ($825/$850). Potential Rents could reach $1,800+ total ($900+ each side)
PROPERTY DETAILS
  • Duplex
  • 4 Beds (2 Beds per side)
  • 2 Baths (1 Bath per side)
  • 1,566 Sqft (783 per side)
  • Long Term Tenants
  • Separate utility meters
  • No repairs needed, just collect cashflow!
  • Very well-maintained
  • Furnaces Both Approx 2013
  • ACs 2019 and Approx 2013
  • Lease Details: 2531 (Start-End 7/8/22 - 7/31/25)
  • Lease Details: 2533 (Start-End 9/24/21 - 9/24/25)
  • Potential Rents could reach $1,800+ total ($900+ each side)
  • Instant Equity
  • Better Value Than On The Market!!
  • The nicest part of the neighborhood. The property is surrounded by 1990's built vinyls!!
  • Current Occupancy Tenant Occupied
  • Occupancy at Close Tenant Occupied
  • Close of Escrow 05/30/25
  • Best Offer Due By TBD
  • Non-Refundable Earnest Money Deposit $ 5,000

MARKET ACTIVITY

SUBJECT PROPERTY : 4 Beds (2/Side) / 2 (1/Side) Baths / 1,566 (783/Side) Fin Sqft

COMPARABLES / RECENT ACTIVITY

  • SOLD $183,500 - 3468 N Dearborn St / 4 Bed / 2 Bath / 1,632 Fin Sqft
  • SOLD $175,000 - 2319 N Gale St / 4 Bed / 3 Bath / 1,724 Fin Sqft
    • Location reduced value
  • SOLD $175,000 - 2921 E 18th St / 4 Bed / 2 Bath / 1,456 Fin Sqft
    • Less sqft
  • SOLD $150,000 - 2002 Adams St / 4 Bed / 2 Bath / 1,456 Fin Sqft
    • Less sqft, No Central AC
  • SOLD $147,000 - 2502 Columbia Ave / 4 Bed / 2 Bath / 1,148 Fin Sqft
    • Much Less Sqft, No Central AC
  • SOLD $143,000 - 2540 Schofield Ave / 4 Bed / 2 Bath / 1,430 Fin Sqft
    • Less Sqft, Worse Condition and Finishes
  • SOLD $140,000 - 2729 Adams St / 4 Bed / 2 Bath / 1,416 Fin Sqft
    • Less Sqft, No Central AC, Lower Rent

    • LINK TO COMPS

    Property details

    2 details the seller has shared

    2 fields

    Property

    · The bones — what the buyer sees first

    Property type

    Multi-unit house

    History & terms

    · Past sales, updates, and deal mechanics

    Reason for sale

    Other

    OfferMarket Loans

    Check your rate

    60 seconds · no credit pull

    Check my rate

    In the neighborhood

    Nearby properties on OfferMarket

    $64,990

    2609 Brookway St, Indianapolis, IN 46218, USA

    $285,000

    800 Barnaby St SE, Washington, DC 20032, USA

    $385,000

    1011 Quebec Place NW, Washington, DC 20010, USA

    $215,000

    4746 Rocky Knob Ln, Indianapolis, IN 46254, USA

    $199,999

    4987 Cardiff Ct, Mays Landing, NJ 08330, USA

    $68,000

    657 27th St SW, Birmingham, AL 35211, USA

    $190,000

    6126 Longwood Ave, Mays Landing, NJ 08330, USA

    $285,000

    Barney Cir SE, Washington, DC 20003, USA

    $179,900

    7438 Gordon Way, Indianapolis, IN 46237, USA

    $206,900

    2109 E 71st St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, USA

    $54,900

    2339 Spann Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA

    $140,000

    2322 Patterson Ave, Winston-Salem, NC 27105, USA

    Browse every listing→