*Quote takes 1 minute, no credit pull
Insurance*1 quote from 40+ carriers
Listings*New listings daily
Landlord Insurance New York
Last updated: May 29, 2025
"The first rule in investment is don't lose and the second rule in investment is don't forget the first rule." - Warren Buffett
Landlord insurance in New York is a specialized insurance solution crafted for owners renting out residential or commercial properties anywhere from Manhattan’s skyscrapers to upstate’s historic neighborhoods. Whether you oversee a brownstone in Brooklyn, an apartment building in Buffalo, or rental homes across Long Island and Westchester, landlord insurance New York is essential to protect your investment and navigate risks unique to the Empire State.
Unlike standard homeowners insurance, landlord insurance policies in New York address the distinct liabilities faced by rental property owners, such as tenant-related claims, building code updates, and weather hazards like nor’easters and heavy snowfalls, which are common in the state.
Over recent years, New York property owners have seen insurance costs escalate, which impacts net rental yields and cash flow. Based on our review of thousands of landlord insurance New York policies, many landlords overpay by as much as 25%—often due to a lack of access to specialized insurance agents or limited familiarity with New York’s insurance landscape.
That’s why OfferMarket Insurance built a platform designed specifically for New York landlords—empowering you to compare landlord insurance quotes from more than 40 providers. Our New York-based insurance advisors review every offer to ensure you receive the best coverage at the most competitive price, helping landlords statewide save significantly every year.
What Risks Does Landlord Insurance in New York Cover?
A comprehensive landlord insurance policy in New York typically provides protection against:
🏠 Property damage from fire, severe wind, winter storms, vandalism, and risks frequent in New York
⚖️ Liability claims in the event someone is injured at your New York rental property
💸 Loss of rental income if a covered incident makes your property uninhabitable
🌊 Flood insurance (requires a separate policy if your New York property is in a FEMA flood zone)
Property Insurance
New York landlords deal with hazards ranging from winter nor’easters and coastal storms to urban fire risks and vandalism. The property insurance component of your landlord insurance New York policy covers these perils and can include relocation costs if tenants must temporarily move out during repairs.
New York property insurance policies are generally offered in three primary coverage forms—Basic, Broad, and Special—each addressing a different set of risks (“perils”):
Basic Form Perils
The most budget-friendly landlord insurance option in New York covers a defined list of basic perils, including:
🔥 Fire
🌩️ Lightning
💥 Internal explosion
Extended Coverage (EC) Perils
In New York, insurers commonly offer extended coverage perils that can be added to your basic policy. A helpful mnemonic—WHARVES—reminds you of the typical extended perils:
🌬️ Windstorm (including damaging winds along the coast and from nor’easters)
🦹♂️ Civil commotion
🔥 Smoke (from sudden, accidental events)
🌨️ Hail (notable in upstate New York)
✈️ Aircraft
🚗 Vehicle impact
💥 Explosion
❗ Riot
For vandalism, insurers use V&MM:
🏚️ Vandalism
🦹♂️ Malicious mischief
Broad Form Perils
New York insurance professionals remember additional broad form perils with the acronym BIG AFFECT:
🥷 Burglary damage
🧊 Ice, sleet, snow (especially damaging during New York winters)
🪟 Glass breakage
🚰 Accidental water or steam discharge
🧊 Freezing objects (crucial for upstate and winter-prone areas)
✈️ Falling objects
⚡ Electrical current damage
🏚️ Collapse
💥 Tearing asunder
Special Form Peril
The most comprehensive landlord insurance for New York property owners is called “Special Form,” “open form,” or “DP-3” (commonly chosen for single-family or luxury rentals). This covers all risks of direct physical loss unless specifically excluded—so it’s important to review your policy exclusions.
Typical exclusions in New York policies include:
🌊 Flooding (separate flood insurance is mandatory in New York flood zones)
🌎 Earthquake (less common in New York, but available as an endorsement)
🤡 Intentional damage
⚠️ Building code enforcement costs (often significant in NYC and older buildings)
🔌 Power failure outside the property
🇺🇸 Government seizure
General Liability Insurance
General liability insurance in New York shields landlords from injury or property damage claims by tenants, visitors, or workers on your rental property. Coverage limits usually range from $100,000 to $1,000,000 per event.
For example, if a tenant slips on icy steps in your New York rental and sues, your landlord insurance New York policy’s liability section helps cover legal fees and medical costs.
Business Interruption Insurance (Loss of Rent)
New York landlords are exposed to the risk of lost rental income if their property becomes uninhabitable after an insured event. Business interruption insurance, included in your landlord insurance New York policy, reimburses lost rent and stabilizes cash flow while repairs are made.
This important coverage is typically affordable in New York, often costing around $1 for every $1,000 of annual rental income.
Flood Insurance
Due to New York’s geography—including proximity to the Hudson River, Long Island Sound, and Atlantic Ocean—flood insurance is vital if your rental is in a FEMA-designated flood zone, such as parts of NYC, Albany, or coastal Long Island.
Many New York lenders require flood insurance coverage of up to $250,000, separate from your landlord insurance New York policy and typically obtained via the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP). You can check your property’s flood risk with FEMA’s Flood Map Service.
Landlord Insurance for DSCR Loans in New York
If you’re financing your New York rental property with a Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) loan, it’s important to understand the insurance requirements set by lenders. New York landlords must secure landlord insurance policies that align with lender expectations to qualify and maintain eligibility for DSCR loans.
Since insurance premiums directly affect your DSCR, choosing affordable yet robust landlord insurance New York policies is crucial for protecting cash flow and supporting loan approval. Here’s what most DSCR lenders in New York typically require:
| DSCR Loan Insurance Requirement | Required? |
|---|---|
| Property Insurance | Yes |
| General Liability Insurance | Yes |
| Business Interruption Insurance | Yes |
| Mortgagee Clause | Yes |
| Lender as Additional Insured | Sometimes |
Our OfferMarket Insurance platform helps New York landlords navigate DSCR loan insurance by providing tailored quotes that meet lender guidelines while minimizing costs.
How Much Does Landlord Insurance Cost in New York?
The cost of landlord insurance in New York depends on several influential factors:
Location
Insurers use regional risk data when setting premiums. For example, rental properties in flood-prone neighborhoods in Manhattan or along the Hudson River may have higher rates than those in less flood-exposed parts of Queens or Syracuse. Local construction costs also affect rates, especially in New York City where labor and materials are at a premium.
Property Insurance Type
New York landlords can select among Basic, Broad, and Special Form coverage. Special Form provides the broadest protection and is generally recommended for rentals, though it carries the highest premium.
| Property Insurance Type | Cost |
|---|---|
| Basic Form | $ |
| Basic + Extended Coverage | $$ |
| Broad Form | $$ |
| Special Form | $$$$ |
Dwelling Coverage Amount
The biggest driver of your New York landlord insurance premium is the amount of dwelling coverage you select. Insuring your property at its full replacement cost value (RCV) is always recommended to avoid coinsurance penalties.
Given New York’s ongoing rise in building costs, it’s smart to review and update your coverage regularly to match current replacement values.
| Dwelling Coverage Type | Cost |
|---|---|
| Actual Cash Value | $ |
| Functional Replacement Cost Value | $$ |
| Replacement Cost Value | $$$ |
Deductible
Opting for a higher deductible lowers your annual premium in New York. Many landlords select deductibles of $5,000 or more to balance out-of-pocket risk with annual savings.
| Deductible | Premium Cost |
|---|---|
| $1,000 | $$$$ |
| $2,500 | $$$$ |
| $5,000 | $$$ |
| $7,500 | $$ |
| $10,000 | $ |
Claim Frequency and Severity
Insurance companies in New York evaluate your personal claims history and the claims history associated with your property. Frequent or severe claims—such as those resulting from water damage in Brooklyn brownstones or wind damage from coastal storms—can raise rates or lead to coverage limitations.
Crime Score Impact
Neighborhood crime rates, particularly in urban areas such as the Bronx, Brooklyn, or Buffalo, affect landlord insurance premiums in New York. Higher crime scores increase risks of vandalism, theft, and liability claims, causing insurers to raise rates or set policy restrictions.
However, crime scores might not reflect all security measures at your property. Investing in monitored security systems or hiring on-site management can help lower your insurance costs.
Property Condition and Maintenance
Well-maintained properties in New York’s varied climate usually enjoy lower insurance premiums. New York landlords should prioritize updates to plumbing, electrical, and HVAC systems to reduce risks like winter pipe bursts or summer humidity damage.
Older properties, especially those in historic neighborhoods or with original materials, may carry higher insurance costs. Keep thorough records of ongoing maintenance and renovations—these documents can positively influence your insurance evaluation and policy terms.
How to Protect Your Rental Property in New York
While landlord insurance New York is a critical safety net, proactive steps can further shield your investment:
Tenant Screening
In New York’s diverse rental markets—from Midtown Manhattan to the college towns of Ithaca and Stony Brook—diligent tenant screening is vital. Conduct thorough credit and background checks for all adult applicants, establish clear standards for approval, and when exceptions are made, require increased deposits or personal guarantors.
Regular Maintenance
New York’s climate variability demands consistent upkeep. Schedule quarterly property inspections to address small issues—such as leaky roofs or faulty boilers—before they become costly claims. Maintaining detailed service logs may help you qualify for insurance discounts.
Tenant Maintenance Education
Educate your New York tenants on preventative tasks like changing HVAC filters, shutting off main water valves in emergencies, and proper use of appliances during cold snaps to avoid water damage.
DP-3 Insurance in New York
DP-3 policies, also known as Special Form coverage, are the gold standard for New York rental properties. This coverage reimburses you for most property damage on a replacement cost basis, excluding only what is listed in the policy.
What is Coinsurance?
Coinsurance clauses penalize New York landlords who underinsure their properties—usually when coverage is below 80% of replacement value. This means you’ll be responsible for a portion of the claim beyond your deductible.
Coinsurance formula
(Insurance Carried ÷ Insurance Required) × Loss = Claim Payment – Deductible
Example:
If your New York rental has a replacement cost of $400,000 but is insured for only $200,000, and you suffer a $60,000 loss with a $5,000 deductible:
($200,000 ÷ $400,000) × $60,000 = $30,000 – $5,000 = $25,000 from insurer.
You cover the remaining $35,000, highlighting the importance of insuring at full replacement value.
/Landlord Insurance Markets in New York
Whether your rental property is located in the fast-paced neighborhoods of Manhattan, the historic streets of Albany, the vibrant communities of Queens, or the scenic regions of upstate New York, we connect you with landlord insurance products specialized for your area.
Best Landlord Insurance in New York
New York landlords face numerous choices when it comes to insurance coverage. We recommend seeking a policy that includes:
Comprehensive property insurance for New York’s regional weather and property risks
General liability insurance for protection from tenant and visitor injuries
Business interruption insurance to safeguard rental income
Flood insurance if your property is in or near a flood zone
Working with an agency experienced in New York landlord insurance and offering access to multiple carriers ensures you secure the right protection at a competitive rate. Get your landlord insurance quote with OfferMarket Insurance today.
Landlord Insurance Guidelines for New York DSCR Loans
Below are best practices for landlord insurance in New York to meet DSCR lender requirements:
Property Insurance
| Coverage Type | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Property Insurance | Mandatory, AM Best Rating A- VIII or higher, 1-year term |
| Limits | 80% of replacement cost or loan amount, whichever is higher |
| Deductible | $5,000 |
| Policy Type | Special Form (Dwelling Fire or Commercial Property) |
| Cancellation Notice | 30 days |
| Lender’s Designation | Mortgagee |
General Liability Insurance
| Requirement | Yes |
|---|---|
| AM Best Rating | A- VIII or higher |
| Limits | $500,000 per occurrence, $1,000,000 aggregate |
| Deductible | $1,000 |
| Coverage | Occurrence basis |
| Cancellation Notice | 30 days |
| Lender’s Designation | Additional Insured |
Business Interruption Insurance
| Requirement | Yes |
|---|---|
| AM Best Rating | A- VIII or higher |
| Limits | One year of gross rental revenue |
| Cancellation Notice | 30 days |
| Lender’s Designation | Mortgagee |
Flood Insurance
| Requirement | Yes (if in flood zone) |
|---|---|
| AM Best Rating | A- VIII or higher |
| Limits | $250,000 or loan balance, whichever is greater |
| Cancellation Notice | 30 days |
| Lender’s Designation | Mortgagee |
Additional Details for New York Landlord Insurance
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Mortgagee Clause | OfferMarket Capital LLC ISAOA/ATIMA 627 S Hanover St Baltimore, MD 21230 |
| Condos and PUDs in NY | Blanket policies permitted if individual units are included; associations must maintain all-risk coverage for common areas and equipment at 100% replacement cost |
| Instructions | Use ACORD forms for compliance. Submit certificates, invoices, or paid receipts at least 24 hours before closing. Final policy documents due within 60 days of closing. Notify your carrier if your property is vacant and obtain a vacancy permit if required. |
Frequently Asked Questions About Landlord Insurance in New York
How does OfferMarket Insurance work for New York landlords?
OfferMarket Insurance is a specialized platform for landlord insurance New York property owners need. We compare quotes from a wide range of carriers, ensuring policies align with your needs and lender requirements. Every quote is reviewed by our experts so you get the best coverage at the best value.
Do I need a Builders Risk Policy in New York?
Builders Risk insurance is not included in a standard landlord insurance New York policy. It is required only if you are renovating, rehabbing, or constructing a rental property. Builders Risk covers your property and materials during construction phases.
Can I use Functional Replacement Cost instead of Replacement Cost Value for my New York rental?
Your lender’s rules will determine this. Many New York lenders allow Functional Replacement Cost, but some require full Replacement Cost Value, depending on the property’s age and condition as shown in your New York appraisal.
Why does my New York lender need to be an Additional Insured?
Some DSCR lenders in New York require being named as Additional Insured to extend liability protection, while the Mortgagee Clause safeguards property rights. Understanding both ensures your New York policy meets lender standards.
Can I use my preferred insurance agent for landlord insurance in New York?
Yes, if your agent can provide competitive landlord insurance New York policies and fully understands New York’s unique requirements. Agents focused solely on personal lines may lack critical landlord insurance expertise, causing potential delays.
Can I pay for landlord insurance on the HUD-1 or ALTA settlement statement in New York?
Most DSCR loans in New York require full payment of landlord insurance premiums at closing, either on the HUD-1/ALTA or directly via your insurance agent prior to settlement.
Can I escrow my landlord insurance premium in New York?
Many institutional lenders in New York require that insurance premiums be escrowed with your monthly mortgage payment to ensure your property always has active coverage.
Can I get a refund if I cancel my New York landlord insurance policy?
Yes, New York insurers must refund any unearned premium on a pro-rated basis. Always secure replacement coverage before canceling to avoid a lapse in protection.
What is an AM Best Rating?
AM Best rates the financial strength of insurance companies. In New York, you should select insurers with an A- VIII or higher rating to ensure dependable coverage.
What is Builders Risk Insurance in New York?
Builders Risk insurance protects New York properties and materials during construction or renovation. It covers risks like fire, theft, wind, and vandalism, and typically ends when construction is complete or the property is occupied.
Protect and grow your portfolio with OfferMarket
OfferMarket is a real estate investing platform focused on serving rental property investors, specifically 1-4 unit residential properties. Our mission is to help you build wealth through real estate.
☂️ Landlord Insurance rate shopping platform specialized in landlord insurance that meets DSCR loan guidelines 🏚️ Off Market Properties marketplace featuring hundreds of exclusive and off market deals posted by wholesalers, tired landlords and distressed sellers. 💰 Private Lending featuring instant quotes and a simple, low cost, transparent borrowing experience for DSCR loans, Fix and Flip loans and Slow Flip loans. 💡 *Insights regularly published to provide you with a knowledge advantage.