Off-Market Archive

No longer actively listed

Off market since September 10, 2026. Photos, details, and location data are preserved for neighborhood research and comparable analysis.

Last listed

$505,000.00

Off-Market

11504 Niagara Dr

Fishers, IN 46037, USA

List price

$505,000

Single family

listing, photo 1
1 / 20
Thumbnail 1
Thumbnail 2
Thumbnail 3
Thumbnail 4
Thumbnail 5
Thumbnail 6
Thumbnail 7
Thumbnail 8
Thumbnail 9
Thumbnail 10
Thumbnail 11
Thumbnail 12
Thumbnail 13
Thumbnail 14
Thumbnail 15
Thumbnail 16
Thumbnail 17
Thumbnail 18
Thumbnail 19
Thumbnail 20

Photos of the property

Explore the location

· from aerial to streetside.

Click to explore Street View
Scroll past freely — Street View won't take over until you activate it.

Story

>>> CLICK HERE FOR ALL DETAILS <<<

11504 Niagara Dr, Fishers, IN 46037
WALKTHROUGH MONDAY, 08/31/26
MUST TEXT 317-751-9601 FOR ACCESS AND TIME

CASH ASKING PRICE
$ 505,000 CASH OR BEST OFFER

AFTER REPAIR VALUE
$ 585,000
Adding Egress would allow additional bedrooms to be added

RENTAL ESTIMATE
$ 2,419
Rent-O-Meter 4-Bed Average

PROPERTY DETAILS
  • SFH
  • Bed: 4
  • Bath: 2.5
  • Sq Ft: 4,067
  • Built: 2000
  • 2-Story Layout
  • Finished Basement
  • Attic: Yes
  • 9-Year-Old HVAC
  • 9-Year-Old Water Heater
  • 2-Car Attached Garage
  • 200-Amp Electrical Service
  • Level Flooring
  • No Paint Needed
  • Windows in Good Condition
  • Doors in Good Condition
  • Adding Egress would allow additional bedrooms to be added
  • Current Occupancy Owner Occupied
  • Occupancy at Close Vacant at Close
  • Close of Escrow 10/19/26
  • Best Offer Due By 09/01/26 12:00 PM
  • Non-Refundable Earnest Money Deposit $ 5,000

MARKET ACTIVITY

https://cdn.carrot.com/uploads/sites/55003/2025/04/Property-Map-Example-IBM.png
SUBJECT PROPERTY: 11504 Niagara Dr / 4 Beds / 2.5 Baths / 4,067 Sqft / 2-Story / Built 2000 / 13,068 Sqft Lot / 2-Car Attached Garage

COMPARABLES / RECENT ACTIVITY

  • SOLD $570,000 – 11280 Walking Wood Ln / 4 Bed / 2 Bath / 2,395 Sqft / Built 1996 / 2 Attached Gar
    • Smaller living area
  • SOLD $563,000 – 10263 Brixton Ln / 5 Bed / 3 Bath / 3,848 Sqft / Built 1996 / 2 Attached Gar
    • One extra bed/bath
    • Smaller living area
  • SOLD $560,000 – 10243 Brixton Ln / 4 Bed / 2 Bath / 3,634 Sqft / Built 1993 / 2 Attached Gar
    • Smaller living area
  • SOLD $536,611 – 11093 Ragsdale Pl / 4 Bed / 2 Bath / 3,326 Sqft / Built 2002 / 3 Attached Gar
    • Smaller living area
  • SOLD $520,000 – 9840 Deering St / 4 Bed / 2 Bath / 3,032 Sqft / Built 1995 / 2 Attached Gar
    • Smaller living area

    • LINK TO COMPS !! JOIN OUR BUYER LIST: https://www.investbelowmarket.com/ !!

    Property details

    2 details the seller has shared

    2 fields

    Property

    · The bones — what the buyer sees first

    Property type

    Single family

    History & terms

    · Past sales, updates, and deal mechanics

    Reason for sale

    Other

    OfferMarket Loans

    Check your rate

    60 seconds · no credit pull

    Check my rate

    In the neighborhood

    Nearby properties on OfferMarket

    $115,000

    2506 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA

    $150,000

    30512 Fox Run Ln, Joplin, MO 64801, USA

    $515,000

    1654 O Brien St, South Bend, IN 46628, USA

    $445,000

    1054 Twincrest Ave, North Las Vegas, NV 89032, USA

    $2,250,000

    2259 Camino Rey, Fullerton, CA 92833, USA

    $30,000

    1236 W 16th Ave, Gary, IN 46407, USA

    4 beds

    2 baths

    $70,000

    1122 Trowbridge St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA

    $54,900

    2501 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA

    $85,000

    4440 Washington St, Gary, IN 46408, USA

    $390,000

    325 Parkland Pl SE, Washington, DC 20032, USA

    $250,000

    1713 Fontain St, Philadelphia, PA 19121, USA

    5 beds

    3 baths

    $240,000

    4509 Magoun Ave, East Chicago, IN 46312, USA

    Browse every listing→